What's the deal with LR3 transmissions anyway

bearskinrug

Well-known member
Looking at 2006 and up LR3s for daily driver/kid hauled. The ones in my hood are 80-180k miles, and a few have had tranys rebuilt or replaced. Is this some inherent flaw, a consequence of the LR service interval, or something else? I'm gonna need some help selling the wife on another rover since I'm putting my garbage D1 to pasture.
 

stu454

Well-known member
Callsign: KN4CBB
I've heard from more than one tech that with regular service they will outlast the rest of the truck.
 

bearskinrug

Well-known member
I've heard from more than one tech that with regular service they will outlast the rest of the truck.

Thanks. Is there something about 80k miles? A lot of people seem to be dumping them at those mikes, but I guess that's about 10k a year so maybe it's just typical use.
 

Ray_G

Well-known member
The price for LR3's at the 10 year mark is making them extremely attractive trucks for a lot of reasons. My personal opinion is that you are getting way more truck for the $ than in many of the previous Discovery generations (even with my bias towards D1's, my LR3/D3 is just a better vehicle across the board when it comes to DD duties).

I'll be interested in Jjmmiejamz or one of the other folks with more time on them at the dealership has to say about the transmissions; if I was laying down odds I'd say you are seeing warrenty replacement work. My understanding is that the drivetrain of the 4.4L is great until you get to the difs and there is where there have been some issues but what is worth noting is 'some issues' is not equivical to 'Dii head gaskets also had some issues' or 'P38's' Meaning the 3 is a vastly better platform reliability wise.

As a DD/kid hauler they are superb. The seven seater is nice if you want to be able to seperate the savages, the way the seats all fold flat provides excellent storage space for those bed, bath, & beyond trips. Comfort on the road is excellent too.

For the 10yr olds entering the market now you should def look for service interval. You should also expect to see an EAS compressor replacement or budget accordingly. As you have probably read these things eat brakes, bushings, and tires due to their weight so also look to see when the lower control arms were done and such.

Still, I'd suggest some test drives, I don't think the better half will be disappointed in the 3.
r-
Ray
 

bearskinrug

Well-known member
The price for LR3's at the 10 year mark is making them extremely attractive trucks for a lot of reasons. My personal opinion is that you are getting way more truck for the $ than in many of the previous Discovery generations (even with my bias towards D1's, my LR3/D3 is just a better vehicle across the board when it comes to DD duties).

I'll be interested in Jjmmiejamz or one of the other folks with more time on them at the dealership has to say about the transmissions; if I was laying down odds I'd say you are seeing warrenty replacement work. My understanding is that the drivetrain of the 4.4L is great until you get to the difs and there is where there have been some issues but what is worth noting is 'some issues' is not equivical to 'Dii head gaskets also had some issues' or 'P38's' Meaning the 3 is a vastly better platform reliability wise.

As a DD/kid hauler they are superb. The seven seater is nice if you want to be able to seperate the savages, the way the seats all fold flat provides excellent storage space for those bed, bath, & beyond trips. Comfort on the road is excellent too.

For the 10yr olds entering the market now you should def look for service interval. You should also expect to see an EAS compressor replacement or budget accordingly. As you have probably read these things eat brakes, bushings, and tires due to their weight so also look to see when the lower control arms were done and such.

Still, I'd suggest some test drives, I don't think the better half will be disappointed in the 3.
r-
Ray

Thank so a ton for all of this.
 

Ray_G

Well-known member
All good man, good to see you over on ExpO. That place is 'happier' in terms of interactions than here or Dweb, but there is a lot of LR3/4 content-you just have to wade through a fair amount of chaff. Each site has its strengths.
r-
Ray
 

WeBeCinYa

Well-known member
On our 2nd LR3, love them. One that has been properly serviced should be a great truck. All the items Ray mentions are about all you will deal with, outside of the diffs hopefully.

Mine just had a strange noise start from the CV joints/half shafts that I'll need to look into, otherwise I couldn't be happier just crossing 78k miles.

Get a PPI, and do tranny service at 100k (unlike what the manual says). Good luck on your search!
 

Al Blue4.6l

Well-known member
I agree re: getting the transmission service at around 100K miles.

Mine is at 130K and is still sailing along. Diffs are the main issue - definitely listen for diff whine. I had the front diff replaced under warranty after I bought it a couple of years ago.
 

jymmiejamz

Founding Member
Callsign: KN4JHI
Tranmission failures are not common at all. Even in NYC, we do very few. I would just recommend cutting all of the factory service intervals in half and doing the fluid and filter at 75k instead of 150k. The most common transmission issue is leaks from the connector sleeve.
 

bearskinrug

Well-known member
Any reason not to look at the big body Range Rover of the same vintage (2006-2009)? They seem to be going for same money at similar mikes and have the third row. I'm not gonna tow anything.
 
Top